Average all of the reviews, and you have things about right. My bet is that some rooms are really good...others not so. We just returned from a weekend in Chicago to see the sights. Bought the Go Chicago card, and used the Grey Line hop on - hop off to get around. We had a standard king room in the south tower on the 13th floor, and observations are as follows:
The Good:
Price - good for downtown from what we could see..it seems downtown Chicago is very expensive..
Location - Excellent, 5 minutes from the art institute, 15 - 20 min walk from planetarium and aquarium, right across the road from Grant Park, near the Grey Line stop, and a pretty easy walk to anywhere in the Loop, with good restaurants close by. Lots to do, so we were'nt in our room very much.
The room and linens were clean, the breakfast downstairs was good, and the staff where friendly and the bed was great.
The 'Could be better"
This place is really OLD. They where doing renovations constantly while we were there, and I get the feeling that they try to do what they can on a budget without gutting the whole place. Someone described the hotel as 'quirky'. I would add 'utilitarian'. If you want a luxury hotel experience, this is not the place to be.spend an extra 100.00 per night. and go somewhere else. If you want a place to sleep at a reasonable price for downtown, it's OK. Be prepared for noisy bathroom fans, doors that might squeek or stick a bit...outdated curtains , wallpaper and decor. The place also has some hidden charm...old marble staircases, old style elevators, etc.
Would I recommend it? If you are on a budget, only need a place to sleep, and plan to be outside most of the time...then yeah.